Keyna Cory, a Florida
lobbyist for the National Solid Waste Management Association, said seven trash collectors have been
killed by drivers who were texting."Our workers are at risk every time they stop," she
said.
Treating a texting ban as a foregone conclusion, Diane Carr, a lobbyist for the Alliance
of Automobile Manufacturers, asked only that language be included to ensure drivers may use
navigation systems that only take asingle touch of a finger to turn on and off.
Jim Messer, a
member of the Florida Justice Association and founder of the Text Free Driving Organization, said
Allstate Insurance found that driving while textingis equivalent to driving after drinking four
beers.
Actually, a search of Allstate's Web site turns up the
claim in a section urging teens to pledge not to text while driving. But a citation below the
claim links to a report of a 2005 University of Utah study comparing reaction times of intoxicated
drivers with drivers talking on cellphones. It found users of hand-held and hands-free cell phone
devices were equally impaired.
The study, which did not measure drivers who were texting,
found that cell phone users had more accidents than intoxicated users but added the cell phone
users' impairments disappeared as soon as they hung up.
Rep. Mike Horner, R-Kissimmee, said
"broad consensus" had been reached on the texting ban but asked for more input on the proposed cell
phone restrictions. Discussion also focused on whether police would be allowed to pull over
suspectedviolators or issue citations only if they stop a motorist for a different
offense.
Rep. Richard Steinberg, D-Miami Beach, said"we've probably all texted while driving
and we did it because we thought it was safe." But not allowing police to pull motorists over for
texting is like "telling people to do it if you think it's safe todo it."
Support
for the text-ban proposal was not unanimous onthe committee. Rep. Steven Precourt, R-Orlando, said
existing laws banning careless driving should be enough.
"Banning use of technology could lead
you down a slippery slope . . . to banning anything at all that increases risk," he
said.
Reached by phone later Wednesday, Rep. Pat Patterson, R-DeLand, said he'd
liketo see a text-ban bill that "has some teeth" and will be enforced as a serious problem. "I hate
it when we do legislation that's nothing more than a stop sign," he said. "Stop signs don't stop
cars."
In ane-mail statement, Volusia County Sheriff Ben Johnson said he favors banning
texting while driving because it could help avoid deadly consequences. The Sheriff's Office recently
banned its employees from texting while driving department vehicles. Violators are subject to
disciplinary action, up to and including dismissal, sheriff's spokesman Brandon Haught
said.
By the numbers
19 states, plus Guam and the District of Columbia, ban text messaging for
all drivers. In 15 of those states, police can pull over drivers suspected of
texting.
6 states (California, Connecticut, NewJersey, New York, Oregon and Washington) ban
all drivers from talkingon handheld cell phones while driving.
0 states completely ban all
types of cell phones (handheld and hands-free) for all drivers.